Skip To Main Content

Book Challenge and Reconsideration Process

Who can challenge a book or instructional resource?

EF Local: A parent of a District student, any employee, or any District resident may formally challenge an instructional resource used in the District’s educational program on the basis of appropriateness.

What are the reconsideration processes?

EF Local: Informal Reconsideration

  1. The principal or designee shall explain the school’s selection process, the criteria for selection, and the qualifications of the professional staff who selected the questioned resource.
  2. The principal or designee shall explain the intended educational purpose of the resource and any additional information regarding its use.
  3. If appropriate, the principal or designee may offer a concerned parent an alternative instructional resource to be used by that parent’s child in place of the challenged resource.
  4. If the complainant wishes to make a formal challenge, the principal or designee shall provide the complainant a copy of this policy and a form to request a formal reconsideration of the resource.

EF Local: Formal Reconsideration

A complainant shall make any formal objection to an instructional resource on the form provided by the District and shall submit the completed and signed form to the principal. Upon receipt of the form, the principal shall appoint a reconsideration committee. The reconsideration committee shall include at least one member of the instructional staff who has experience using the challenged resource with students or is familiar with the challenged resource’s content. Other members of the committee may include District level staff, library staff, secondary-level students, parents, and any other appropriate individuals. All members of the committee shall review the challenged resource in its entirety. As soon as reasonably possible, the committee shall meet and determine whether the challenged resource conforms to the principles of selection set out in this policy. The committee shall prepare a written report of its findings and provide copies to the principal, the Superintendent or designee, and the complainant.

EF Local: Appeal

The complainant may appeal the decision of the reconsideration committee in accordance with appropriate complaint policies, starting with the appropriate administrator. [See DGBA, FNG, and GF] 

What does the formal reconsideration committee consider when making a decision?

EF Legal: 

Students’ First Amendment rights are implicated by the removal of books from the shelves of a school library. A school district cannot remove materials from a library for the purpose of denying students access to ideas with which the district disagrees. A district may remove materials because they are pervasively vulgar or based solely upon the educational suitability of the books in question. Bd. of Educ. v. Pico, 457 U.S. 853 (1982)

EF Local: 

The committee decides if a book is educationally suitable or pervasively vulgar by determining the appropriateness of the resource for its intended educational use. No challenged instructional resource shall be removed solely because of the ideas expressed therein.  

Carroll ISD is in the process of reviewing the policies of EF Legal and Local in relation to current processes and procedures.  Carroll ISD is also in the process of evaluating processes and procedures when considering educational suitability in addition to age and content appropriateness.

The digital reconsideration form may be accessed at each campus library page.

Carroll Elementary School

Johnson Elementary School

Old Union Elementary School

Rockenbaugh Elementary School

Walnut Grove Elementary School

Durham Intermediate School

Eubanks Intermediate School

Carroll Middle School

Dawson Middle School

Carroll High School

Carroll Senior High School